LyricsToSongAI vs MakeSong
Updated onCompare LyricsToSongAI and MakeSong side-by-side. See how they stack up on features, pricing, and target market.
LyricsToSongAI
LyricsToSongAI is a web-based AI music generator that turns text or lyrics into fully produced, royalty-free songs with vocals and instrumentation for creators and musicians.
Starts at $0 / month
vs
MakeSong
AI song generator that converts prompts into full songs and offers subscription and credit pricing tiers for creators who want downloadable, commercial‑use tracks.
Starts at $7.9 / per month / month
Which should you choose?
LyricsToSongAI
Choose LyricsToSongAI if you want a browser-based song generator with deeper creative control (multi-track editing, section-level regeneration, vocal separation and a song-video/visualizer roadmap) and don’t mind a slightly more complex interface
MakeSong
Choose MakeSong if you want a very simple prompt-to-song workflow with generous initial free usage, strong vocal-focused generation, and a mature ecosystem geared toward quick background tracks and social/content use
Typical cost comparison
Scenario: Solo creator on an annual plan using the first paid tier of each tool for commercial songs.
LyricsToSongAI
$7.9 per month
MakeSong
$7.9 per month
Both are equally priced in this scenario
Key differences
| Category | LyricsToSongAI | MakeSong | Why? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing Flexibility | Both offer always-free tiers plus broadly similar entry-level paid plans in the high single digits per month on annual billing, so overall cost depends more on how many songs or credits you need than on big list-price differences. | ||
| Community & Maturity | MakeSong has been live since 2023 with a large public song gallery and multiple directory listings, while LyricsToSongAI launched around 2025 and has a smaller but growing presence. | ||
| Ease of Use | MakeSong’s two main modes (Lyrics and Description) and visible credits system are designed to be very beginner-friendly, whereas LyricsToSongAI’s richer control set can feel closer to a lightweight DAW that may take longer to learn. | ||
| Feature Depth & Editing | LyricsToSongAI emphasizes advanced workflows like multi-track editing, vocal separation, song extension, and an AI song video creator, while MakeSong focuses more on streamlined generation plus a few editing tools like extend, cover, and section replacement. | ||
| Free Tier & On-Ramp | MakeSong’s free tier typically allows around 10 royalty-free songs per account for commercial use, whereas LyricsToSongAI’s free plan only covers roughly a couple of songs per month before you need extra credits or a subscription. |
Feature comparison
| Feature | LyricsToSongAI | MakeSong | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built-in AI lyrics generator | LyricsToSongAI offers a dedicated multi-language AI Lyrics Generator, while MakeSong includes an unlimited song-lyrics generator for prompts and themes. | ||
| Commercial-use rights included | Both position outputs as royalty-free for commercial use; LyricsToSongAI’s tables list a commercial license even on the free plan though some reviews note licensing clarity issues, while MakeSong explicitly advertises 100% royalty-free songs for commercial projects including on its free tier. | ||
| Entry-level paid plan (annual, per month) | Recent pricing pages show first paid tiers at roughly $7.9/month on annual billing for both tools, with higher tiers adding more credits, concurrency, and storage. | ||
| Free tier | LyricsToSongAI provides a limited free tier (roughly two songs per month plus referral-based credits), while MakeSong free accounts can generate about ten royalty-free songs with commercial rights. | ||
| Lyrics-to-song (turn existing lyrics into music) | Each allows you to paste lyrics, choose genre/mood, and produce a structured song with verses and choruses. | ||
| Prompt-to-song (text description to full track) | Both services generate complete songs (vocals and instrumentation) from natural language prompts without requiring musical skills. | ||
| Song extension / section regeneration | LyricsToSongAI has a Song Extension feature, and MakeSong offers Extend Song and Replace Section tools to lengthen or tweak generated music. | ||
| Upload and use reference audio | LyricsToSongAI supports hybrid workflows where you upload a melody or reference track along with text, and MakeSong lets you upload songs for covers, vocal removal, and extension. | ||
| Vocal remover / stem separation | LyricsToSongAI includes AI vocal separation and stem extraction; MakeSong provides Vocal Remover and an Instrumental AI Splitter for isolating elements of a track. | ||
| Multi-track editing in browser | LyricsToSongAI highlights multi-track editing, section-level regeneration, and separate vocal/instrument tracks, whereas MakeSong mainly lets you modify or replace sections of whole songs rather than do full multi-track mixing. | ||
| Real-time collaboration / shared projects | OpenTools lists real-time collaboration and instant sharing for LyricsToSongAI, whereas MakeSong emphasizes individual creation and a public gallery rather than live multi-user editing. | ||
| Song video / visualizer generation | LyricsToSongAI markets an AI Song Video Creator and visualizer as a key or upcoming feature, while MakeSong currently focuses on audio output only. |
Review Consensus
LyricsToSongAI
"Overall sentiment on LyricsToSongAI is moderately positive: users like its powerful, flexible feature set but note variable output quality and some ambiguity around licensing and limits. "
Based on 12 reviews
- ● Generates fully produced songs with vocals and instruments directly from text or lyrics.
- ● Offers extra utilities like vocal separation, song extension, and high-quality exports in one browser-based tool.
- ● Includes a free tier so users can try core capabilities before subscribing.
- ● Song quality and coherence can vary noticeably between generations.
- ● Feature-rich interface can feel overwhelming to casual or first-time users.
- ● Some reviewers find commercial licensing terms and plan limits a bit confusing across different pages.
Data as of 1/1/2026
- ● Praised for flexible creation modes including lyrics-first, melody-first, and mixed workflows.
- ● Noted for multi-track editing, section regeneration, and natural-language control over mood and style.
- ● Appreciated as an intuitive, low-friction way to experiment with AI music without upfront cost.
- ● Critiques mention that details on commercial usage rights are not always clearly surfaced.
- ● Output mix and polish may fluctuate depending on how specific the user’s prompts are.
- ● Lacks the full-depth mixing and mastering controls of dedicated DAWs, which may limit advanced producers.
Data as of 1/1/2026
MakeSong
"Across directories, MakeSong is viewed as a convenient, vocal-strong prompt-to-song tool with helpful stem features, but reviews also flag occasional style mismatches and a credit system that some users find confusing. "
Based on 10 reviews
- ● Lets users turn short text prompts or lyrics into royalty-free songs across many genres.
- ● Provides useful extras like Vocal Remover and Instrumental AI Splitter for remixing and karaoke use.
- ● Free tier is attractive for creators who only need a small batch of songs initially.
- ● Some users report inconsistent matching of genre or tempo to more complex prompts.
- ● Credit-based usage and plan limits can feel confusing or restrictive to new users.
- ● A few reviewers were disappointed with aspects of quality or support compared to expectations.
Data as of 1/1/2026
Based on 1 reviews
- ● Described as an easy way to craft high-quality, royalty-free music from prompts or lyrics.
- ● Includes vocal-processing tools that broaden use cases beyond simple generation.
- ● Supports multiple languages and commercial licensing, making it useful for varied projects.
- ● Limited number of user reviews makes it hard to gauge reliability comprehensively.
- ● Some feedback notes occasional mismatches between requested and generated styles.
- ● Advanced needs like precise stem control or DAW-level editing may require other tools.
Data as of 1/1/2026
Based on 1 reviews
- ● Highlights MakeSong as an all-in-one AI music generator covering text-to-music, covers, stems and mastering.
- ● Emphasizes ease of use and strong-sounding AI vocals that feel close to human singers.
- ● Notes good fit for gaming, podcasts, and advertising use cases with quick turnaround.
- ● Rating is based on very few user reviews, so it may skew more positive than the broader user base.
- ● Does not deeply cover limitations like storage windows or credit accounting.
- ● Community feedback elsewhere suggests results can still be hit-or-miss for niche genres.
Data as of 1/1/2026
Stay Ahead
Don't just find competitors. Track them.
Auto-discover new competitors as they emerge. Get alerts when they change pricing, features, ads, or messaging.
Competitor Monitoring
For founders who'd rather build than manually track competitors.
Starts at
$29 /month
Start with a 14-day free trial. No credit card required.
Stop checking competitor websites manually. Get alerts when something important happens.
Auto Competitor Discovery
New competitors detected automatically as they emerge. Never get blindsided.
Website Tracking
Pricing, features, messaging, and page changes monitored daily
News & Social Monitoring
News mentions, Reddit posts, and competitor announcements
SEO & Ads Intelligence
Keyword rankings, backlinks, and Google Ads creatives
AI Signal Detection
Filters out noise, surfaces only what matters
Email & Slack Alerts
Daily digests delivered where your team already works